The 'care economy' is a recently coined term that refers to unremunerated work undertaken within the home and volunteer activities in the community that maintain the social fabric. Research indicates that almost 90% of global illness care is provided in the home. It is generally recognized that women and girls are the principle caregivers, due to a confluence of gendered family roles and patriarchal societal structures. If you approach the issue from an economic perspective, the unpayed work performed by women can be valued at around 11 trillion.
By Tina Parhakar
Despite the economic and even more important intrinsic value of women’s contribution, their care work has not been integrated into national income accounting systems. Nor have unpaid care workers been sufficiently supported. The economics are difficult to evaluate when taking into account the fact that women and girls are forced to leave paid jobs, schooling and other opportunities to provide care. This is referred to as the 'care gap' where women frequently subsidize social development sectors with their own time, resources and energy.
With a growing elderly population in Western countries and the HIV/AIDS epidemic having a growing toll in Africa and Asia, a disproportionate number of women and girls are being drawn into formal and informal care giving roles that remain embedded in a value system whereby such responsibilities and efforts are given little recognition. According to UNAIDS, in Africa twice as many young women were living with HIV as young men in 2004. Cultural norms and societal expectations on women along with a lack of health services make women not only physiologically and socially more vulnerable to infection but also more likely to bear the burden of the societal impacts of the disease.
Meanwhile, traditional government structures seem to implicitly rely on reconstructing a nostalgic family that never existed, and there is continued resistance from local, national and international policymakers to explicitly address this impending crisis. These structures and individuals must be pressured for solutions that address diverse families and communities as they grow more vulnerable, fractured, and ultimately, overworked.
While the economist Diane Elson notes that 'there is a risk the use of the term “care” will mystify the relationship between the provider and the receiver,' she ultimately recognizes that the concept 'signals the fundamental importance of interpersonal attention to other people's needs in the maintenance of human societies' (2003). The role of feminists, in addition to making ourselves visible, is to provide an alternative definition for the 'care economy' phenomenon. Creating a space for changed emphasis, which may include alternative buzzwords such as 'productive care' or 'a caring economy,' whereby caregiving and all other work is valued for its contribution to overall well-being (rather than for its addition to an indicator such as GDP) may be a significant improvement.
A second and related area ripe for feminist research is how to decrease the influence of the tropes of femininity and masculinity that complicate agency, choice and freedom when it comes to caregiving. Many women feel they must fulfill obligations tied to love and concern for their relations while many men are structurally constrained from fathering and other caregiving functions, for example, through the idea of 'breadwinner.' So to conclude, next year's conference is sure to be a meeting of minds that has as its goal a more intergenerationally and intragenerationally interconnected and equitable world.
This article has been published in Daily Visions 11-10-2008
Saturday, 11 October 2008
Wendy Harcourt: CHALLENGING MAINSTREAMS
After four years of being the chair of the WIDE board, Wendy Hartcourt decided to resign. Daily Visions asked her about her experiences with WIDE.
by Mirjana Dokmanovic
How do you see the development of the WIDE network?
WIDE started after the Nairobi World Conference in 1985. Since then WIDE has passed different phases. It started as an initiative of enthusiastic women who wanted to support each other. After getting funds from the EU and moving its office from Ireland to Brussels, its work has been more focused on EU policy. WIDE focused on economic and trade issues from a gender perspective, and more and more started to tackle feminist issues.
In your presentation on Situating Feminisms in Europe Today, you have stressed the importance of challenging mainstream development, to raise questions and rethink alternatives. Development as perceived and practiced by global corporate actors is not working for all people, and it increases gender disparities and fundamentalism.
How can women counter these negative tendencies?
Women should not only work in women's movements, but should get into positions of political power, to be present on decision making places. Additionally, it is important to question where the money for women’s rights is, and where the money for NGOs goes.
We also need to sharpen critical thinking of development issues. Integration of feminist economics analytical thinking would help to develop alternatives to neoliberal policies.
It is also important to engage with other social movements, such as the European Social Forum and the World Social Forum, in which male approaches prevails.
In my book Body Politics in Development, I wanted to be honest about what is going on behind the scene. Development is created in big UN and corporate meetings. It is not a democratic process at all.
What can WIDE do? What can we do?
WIDE will continue to do critical analysis, and also build the capacity of women. It is important to work on development from feminist perspective, to be included in the trade debate, and to exchange different experiences to understand how we can respond better. After this conference, we should continue our debate in order to foster developing alternatives for the sake of all women and more just world.
Wendy is the Editor-in-Chief and Senior Adviser of the Development Journal of the Society for International Development. Born Australian, she moved to Great Britain in 1985 to finish her PhD studies at Oxford University. She jointed WIDE at the early stages of this network, and was a member of its Steering Group from 1987 to 1995.
by Mirjana Dokmanovic
How do you see the development of the WIDE network?
WIDE started after the Nairobi World Conference in 1985. Since then WIDE has passed different phases. It started as an initiative of enthusiastic women who wanted to support each other. After getting funds from the EU and moving its office from Ireland to Brussels, its work has been more focused on EU policy. WIDE focused on economic and trade issues from a gender perspective, and more and more started to tackle feminist issues.
In your presentation on Situating Feminisms in Europe Today, you have stressed the importance of challenging mainstream development, to raise questions and rethink alternatives. Development as perceived and practiced by global corporate actors is not working for all people, and it increases gender disparities and fundamentalism.
How can women counter these negative tendencies?
Women should not only work in women's movements, but should get into positions of political power, to be present on decision making places. Additionally, it is important to question where the money for women’s rights is, and where the money for NGOs goes.
We also need to sharpen critical thinking of development issues. Integration of feminist economics analytical thinking would help to develop alternatives to neoliberal policies.
It is also important to engage with other social movements, such as the European Social Forum and the World Social Forum, in which male approaches prevails.
In my book Body Politics in Development, I wanted to be honest about what is going on behind the scene. Development is created in big UN and corporate meetings. It is not a democratic process at all.
What can WIDE do? What can we do?
WIDE will continue to do critical analysis, and also build the capacity of women. It is important to work on development from feminist perspective, to be included in the trade debate, and to exchange different experiences to understand how we can respond better. After this conference, we should continue our debate in order to foster developing alternatives for the sake of all women and more just world.
Wendy is the Editor-in-Chief and Senior Adviser of the Development Journal of the Society for International Development. Born Australian, she moved to Great Britain in 1985 to finish her PhD studies at Oxford University. She jointed WIDE at the early stages of this network, and was a member of its Steering Group from 1987 to 1995.
This article was published in Daily Visions 11-10-2008
Labels:
Mirjana Dokmanovic,
Wendy Hartcourt,
WIDE
RADIOPROGRAM at WIDE!
Three opinions from the audience
Helga Neumayer asked three newcomers to WIDE Annual Conference (AC) for their impressions.
Listen to the radio program on: www.fonkel.net/AudienceVoices_final.wav
(click on the link to download the program, it will take up to 3 minutes to download)
Katrin Pelzer is a young women´s labour rights campaigner in the area of informal work from Austria. She heard about the conference because she is a member of the Austria WIDE network. After discovering the programme and speakers, she decided to attend. To her, the EU and its role means a daily struggle in her work. Especially when it comes to the terms of funding women´s labour rights. Sometimes she feels frustrated by it, but coming to WIDE and seeing all the different women working in various areas gives her power and more insights. At WIDE her confidence in her work grows. Day two of the conference was about the EU and its role. For Katrin, this day was the most inspiring, because she saw emotionally committed and experienced women in the panel. For her it is important to go home with concrete ideas that she can apply in her work.
Seconde Nyanzobe is a trainer at 'Search for Common Ground' in Burundi. Though she was in the Netherlands before, this has been her first WIDE conference. She was asked to come here as a keynote speaker on the topic of 1325 resolution by the Women´s Peacemaker Program. In the European Commission she observed that many times it does not really act according to the conditions and contexts of Africa. In a post conflict country, for example, or in a system with restorative justice, women are usually traumatized. And sometimes the same perpetrators continue to abuse women in the post-conflict transition. A real support for transitional justice has to consider the context. Also, the salary cuts that many educated women have had to take has been a big problem. This also affects many children.
Seconde learnt many things at the congress and she will share this at home within her network. She has a suggestion for WIDE: decentralize to other countries and to let other organisations know what is done, so they could be better prepared to act.
Mekka Abdelgabar is based in The Hague, where she chairs the 'Netherlands-Darfur Women Foundation'. She knew about the WIDE conference through a working group on resolution 1325. To her, the European Union means that the projects she is working on are funded here. It also implies that the Netherlands is playing a role in solving the conflict in Darfur, but at the same time, they are supporting the rebels. All this together with the Sudanese government, which makes things more complicated, also makes finding a solution more difficult. People, and especially women on the ground, are suffering and the problem should be solved as quickly as possible. Every day counts. Europeans are not doing much and Darfur is becoming forgotten.
At the conference she saw strong women, and that is what she takes home. But she feels sorry that nobody from Sudan was here, since it´s the largest country in Africa. She hopes that this will be different next year, because in Darfur are a lot of active women’s civil society movements.
Helga Neumayer asked three newcomers to WIDE Annual Conference (AC) for their impressions.
Listen to the radio program on: www.fonkel.net/AudienceVoices_final.wav
(click on the link to download the program, it will take up to 3 minutes to download)
Katrin Pelzer is a young women´s labour rights campaigner in the area of informal work from Austria. She heard about the conference because she is a member of the Austria WIDE network. After discovering the programme and speakers, she decided to attend. To her, the EU and its role means a daily struggle in her work. Especially when it comes to the terms of funding women´s labour rights. Sometimes she feels frustrated by it, but coming to WIDE and seeing all the different women working in various areas gives her power and more insights. At WIDE her confidence in her work grows. Day two of the conference was about the EU and its role. For Katrin, this day was the most inspiring, because she saw emotionally committed and experienced women in the panel. For her it is important to go home with concrete ideas that she can apply in her work.
Seconde Nyanzobe is a trainer at 'Search for Common Ground' in Burundi. Though she was in the Netherlands before, this has been her first WIDE conference. She was asked to come here as a keynote speaker on the topic of 1325 resolution by the Women´s Peacemaker Program. In the European Commission she observed that many times it does not really act according to the conditions and contexts of Africa. In a post conflict country, for example, or in a system with restorative justice, women are usually traumatized. And sometimes the same perpetrators continue to abuse women in the post-conflict transition. A real support for transitional justice has to consider the context. Also, the salary cuts that many educated women have had to take has been a big problem. This also affects many children.
Seconde learnt many things at the congress and she will share this at home within her network. She has a suggestion for WIDE: decentralize to other countries and to let other organisations know what is done, so they could be better prepared to act.
Mekka Abdelgabar is based in The Hague, where she chairs the 'Netherlands-Darfur Women Foundation'. She knew about the WIDE conference through a working group on resolution 1325. To her, the European Union means that the projects she is working on are funded here. It also implies that the Netherlands is playing a role in solving the conflict in Darfur, but at the same time, they are supporting the rebels. All this together with the Sudanese government, which makes things more complicated, also makes finding a solution more difficult. People, and especially women on the ground, are suffering and the problem should be solved as quickly as possible. Every day counts. Europeans are not doing much and Darfur is becoming forgotten.
At the conference she saw strong women, and that is what she takes home. But she feels sorry that nobody from Sudan was here, since it´s the largest country in Africa. She hopes that this will be different next year, because in Darfur are a lot of active women’s civil society movements.
Labels:
Helga Neumayer,
Katrin Pelzer,
Mekka Abdelgabar,
radio,
Seconde Nyanzobe,
WIDE
Friday, 10 October 2008
Highlights from day one: EUROPE versus WOMEN, part one
When you want to change the world, the first question to ask is 'who makes the decisions?' During the first day of the Wide conference, Amandine Bach challenged the conference participants to find these (in)visible forces in Europe. In a heated debate, Bach kept returning to that one important question: 'How can we challenge the main policy actors that shape women's position?'
By Mirjana Dokmanovic
Finding the answers to this question is not an easy task. To start with, the participants of the Parallel Session 'Europe, Europeans & European global players of today in the context of globalisation' had difficulties on agreeing about the concept of 'Europe'. Keywords started to buzz around the room: Democracy! Human rights! Diversity! But also: Migrants! Sexism! Fortress! Consumerism! And not to forget, a hypocritical attitude of paternalism toward the South. Europe shows itself as a social democracy, but it cannot hide the fact that Europe is first and foremost market oriented, in which corporations play a crucial role.
The session participants identified corporations, governments, and citizens as angles of a triangular constructed Europe. These many faces of Europe bring both opportunities and threats. It enables economic development, but at the same time, it produces unemployment, insecurity and demands opening up national economies to big European corporate players in favor of very small elite.
So, how can we, as feminists, react?

This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
By Mirjana Dokmanovic
Finding the answers to this question is not an easy task. To start with, the participants of the Parallel Session 'Europe, Europeans & European global players of today in the context of globalisation' had difficulties on agreeing about the concept of 'Europe'. Keywords started to buzz around the room: Democracy! Human rights! Diversity! But also: Migrants! Sexism! Fortress! Consumerism! And not to forget, a hypocritical attitude of paternalism toward the South. Europe shows itself as a social democracy, but it cannot hide the fact that Europe is first and foremost market oriented, in which corporations play a crucial role.
The session participants identified corporations, governments, and citizens as angles of a triangular constructed Europe. These many faces of Europe bring both opportunities and threats. It enables economic development, but at the same time, it produces unemployment, insecurity and demands opening up national economies to big European corporate players in favor of very small elite.
So, how can we, as feminists, react?
This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
Labels:
2008,
Amandine Bach,
Europe,
forces in Europe,
Mirjana Dokmanovic,
WIDE,
Wo=men
Highlights from day one: EUROPE versus WOMEN, part two
In a heated debate about the major players in European decision making, WIDE participants managed to find some starting points in the battle for a better world.
By Esmeralda Tijhoff
Power has become so fragmented that it is hard to identify the people exercising this power. Activists must work together with scientists to locate these 'moving targets' of power. The EU seems almost 'supernatural'; nobody seems to know where it starts and where it ends. There are so many changing institutions involved that it is difficult to gain up to date knowledge about its activities, let alone how to hold it accountable.
To tackle this problem of 'superman', feminists have to deconstruct the notion of government, as well as the EU. If we talk about 'the' government, we have to put names next to the actions. Who are we talking about, and where do these people go when they leave politics and move to corporations?
Fears and opportunities
As many of you will have noticed, Europe has experienced a move 'to the right' in politics. Political parties from the right are gaining more votes. Although feminists are concerned by this move, we have failed to take the fears of ordinary people in the streets seriously.
Criminal networks are also growing because they provide people with social security and jobs. 'What do I say to the single mother with no job who grows a couple of marijuana plants in her attic?' one participants said. 'We lack the tools to address these issues!'
Feminist activists and scholars have to be engaged with the people and see, even experience, how these people are really grounded in their daily lives. Once we've located the fears and concerns of the people, we can come up with acceptable alternatives.
This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
By Esmeralda Tijhoff
Power has become so fragmented that it is hard to identify the people exercising this power. Activists must work together with scientists to locate these 'moving targets' of power. The EU seems almost 'supernatural'; nobody seems to know where it starts and where it ends. There are so many changing institutions involved that it is difficult to gain up to date knowledge about its activities, let alone how to hold it accountable.
To tackle this problem of 'superman', feminists have to deconstruct the notion of government, as well as the EU. If we talk about 'the' government, we have to put names next to the actions. Who are we talking about, and where do these people go when they leave politics and move to corporations?
Fears and opportunities
As many of you will have noticed, Europe has experienced a move 'to the right' in politics. Political parties from the right are gaining more votes. Although feminists are concerned by this move, we have failed to take the fears of ordinary people in the streets seriously.
Criminal networks are also growing because they provide people with social security and jobs. 'What do I say to the single mother with no job who grows a couple of marijuana plants in her attic?' one participants said. 'We lack the tools to address these issues!'
Feminist activists and scholars have to be engaged with the people and see, even experience, how these people are really grounded in their daily lives. Once we've located the fears and concerns of the people, we can come up with acceptable alternatives.
This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
Labels:
Esmeralda Tijhoff,
European decision making,
WIDE
Column: Last feminist standing
By Esmeralda Tijhoff
Feminists are an underappreciated, underpayed species, threated to be extinct. And I can prove this. Yes there are about 200 feminists at the Peace Palace in The Hague at the moment. But these people are all concerned about 'the next generation' that seems to be preoccupied with consumerism. In the plenary session of day one, the question was posed: 'Who is concerned about the young feminists'? And all hands rose. But nobody asks who of the participants belongs to this so called 'next generation'.
I thought I did. But then again, I am already 27 years old, and that is pretty old in this world. Yet, on all the pictures of the Second Feminist Wave, I do not see girls of 16 years old. Then why do these women over 30 complain that todays girls are not interested in feminism? As I see it, you can be a rebel at 16, but you will become a feminist when you are over 20. If you are really worried about feminism, try to offer this future generation a job or internship in your organization.
Are feminists under payed? Well, yeah! More then 90% of the participants at WIDE stated to have done volunteer work in the last month, e.g. underpayed work. And how many feminists in the room do you think earn more then 5.000 dollars as a feminists? That would be zero. But then surely, there were no feminists in the room earning less then the minimum wage? But that's where you're wrong. These women might not have been quick to stand up, but I know for a fact that they are among us.
And are we feminists underappreciated? Yes. We don't even present ourselves as 'experts'. No, we are 'activists', and sometimes we like to see ourselves as 'professional NGO worker'. Now do you understand why feminists are so badly payed? You have to pay big time for an expert, but you can hire someone with an opinion almost for free!
This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
Feminists are an underappreciated, underpayed species, threated to be extinct. And I can prove this. Yes there are about 200 feminists at the Peace Palace in The Hague at the moment. But these people are all concerned about 'the next generation' that seems to be preoccupied with consumerism. In the plenary session of day one, the question was posed: 'Who is concerned about the young feminists'? And all hands rose. But nobody asks who of the participants belongs to this so called 'next generation'.
I thought I did. But then again, I am already 27 years old, and that is pretty old in this world. Yet, on all the pictures of the Second Feminist Wave, I do not see girls of 16 years old. Then why do these women over 30 complain that todays girls are not interested in feminism? As I see it, you can be a rebel at 16, but you will become a feminist when you are over 20. If you are really worried about feminism, try to offer this future generation a job or internship in your organization.
Are feminists under payed? Well, yeah! More then 90% of the participants at WIDE stated to have done volunteer work in the last month, e.g. underpayed work. And how many feminists in the room do you think earn more then 5.000 dollars as a feminists? That would be zero. But then surely, there were no feminists in the room earning less then the minimum wage? But that's where you're wrong. These women might not have been quick to stand up, but I know for a fact that they are among us.
And are we feminists underappreciated? Yes. We don't even present ourselves as 'experts'. No, we are 'activists', and sometimes we like to see ourselves as 'professional NGO worker'. Now do you understand why feminists are so badly payed? You have to pay big time for an expert, but you can hire someone with an opinion almost for free!
This article has been published in Daily Visions 10-10-2008
Labels:
Esmeralda Tijhoff,
feminists,
WIDE
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
